# Best Orthopedic Surgeons in Evansville, IN (October 2026)

Updated October 2026. Source: https://bestdocs.us/indiana/orthopedic-surgeons/evansville/

Dr. Paul Perry ranks first with a score of 89.7: 5.0 stars from 703 Google reviews; 38 years since medical school; accepts Medicare assignment. Dr. Michael Boyd ranks second with a score of 84.7: 5.0 stars from 336 Google reviews; 26 years since medical school; accepts Medicare assignment. Dr. Timothy Hamby ranks third with a score of 84.5: 4.9 stars from 639 Google reviews; 28 years since medical school; accepts Medicare assignment.

1. **Paul Perry, MD** — Orthopedic Surgeon, Evansville, IN. Score 89.7. Google 5.0 from 703 reviews; 38 years since medical school; accepts Medicare assignment. [Profile](https://bestdocs.us/doctor/paul-perry-orthopedic-surgeon-evansville-1861490450/)
2. **Michael Boyd, DO** — Orthopedic Surgeon, Evansville, IN. Score 84.7. Google 5.0 from 336 reviews; 26 years since medical school; accepts Medicare assignment. [Profile](https://bestdocs.us/doctor/michael-boyd-orthopedic-surgeon-evansville-1538107818/)
3. **Timothy Hamby, MD** — Orthopedic Surgeon, Evansville, IN. Score 84.5. Google 4.9 from 639 reviews; 28 years since medical school; accepts Medicare assignment. [Profile](https://bestdocs.us/doctor/timothy-hamby-orthopedic-surgeon-evansville-1356348130/)
4. **Andrew Saltzman, MD** — Orthopedic Surgeon, Evansville, IN. Score 83.3. Google 4.8 from 357 reviews; 42 years since medical school; accepts Medicare assignment. [Profile](https://bestdocs.us/doctor/andrew-saltzman-orthopedic-surgeon-evansville-1053318865/)
5. **Glenn Johnson, MD** — Orthopedic Surgeon, Evansville, IN. Score 80.4. Google 4.7 from 307 reviews; 34 years since medical school; accepts Medicare assignment. [Profile](https://bestdocs.us/doctor/glenn-johnson-orthopedic-surgeon-evansville-1689672206/)
6. **Zachary Hamby, MD** — Orthopedic Surgeon, Evansville, IN. Score 78.2. Google 4.9 from 613 reviews; 22 years since medical school; accepts Medicare assignment. [Profile](https://bestdocs.us/doctor/zachary-hamby-orthopedic-surgeon-evansville-1952568032/)
7. **Brett Weinzapfel, MD** — Orthopedic Surgeon, Evansville, IN. Score 76.2. Google 4.8 from 49 reviews; 25 years since medical school; accepts Medicare assignment; enrolled in Illinois Medicaid. [Profile](https://bestdocs.us/doctor/brett-weinzapfel-orthopedic-surgeon-evansville-1861410292/)
8. **Craig Carter, MD** — Orthopedic Surgeon, Evansville, IN. Score 75.1. Google 4.9 from 590 reviews; 19 years since medical school; accepts Medicare assignment. [Profile](https://bestdocs.us/doctor/craig-carter-orthopedic-surgeon-evansville-1194922450/)
9. **Peter Knoll, MD** — Orthopedic Surgeon, Evansville, IN. Score 71.7. Google 4.9 from 409 reviews; 16 years since medical school; accepts Medicare assignment. [Profile](https://bestdocs.us/doctor/peter-knoll-orthopedic-surgeon-evansville-1457669525/)

Ranked by the BestDocs score (https://bestdocs.us/methodology/), weighted toward independent third-party verified patient reviews (60%) over public anonymous reviews (40%). Sponsored placements never change rank.